June 1, 2012
-
Why did you believe?
Those who have never practiced religion often wonder how and why the religious ever began to believe in the first place. And it’s a good question:
What religion (aka which god[s]) did/do you follow? Why did/do you believe? Were you indoctrinated as a child? Were you convinced at a time when you were emotionally vulnerable? Were you deceived?
Comments (19)
Whoa, a 75 minute video? tl;dw
Unfortunately I was very religious until around the 10th grade in high school. I was brainwashed hardcore. I only attended private Catholic schools. The only good thing is that, in spite of that, my parents were not regular church goers. Phew! What a pain that would’ve been. They only went for Palm Sunday and maybe somewhere around Christmas.
So, yeah, I was obviously vulnerable. Like Doug Stanhope says, they push that on you when the skull is still soft and you’re “Santa-eligible.” LOL!
As far as being deceived…well, doesn’t that indicate that the person is aware that what they’re saying is false but they still want to trick you into believing? So, in that sense, I’d say I wasn’t deceived. To this day, they truly believe in all that malarkey, so they weren’t being deceitful.
I was never raised in an overly religious household. I’m from Oklahoma, which on the whole is a pretty darn religious-claiming place. But we were those people who were “Christian” because well, sure we believe in God and Jesus – who doesn’t? But we didn’t go to church regularly or anything, except for a few years, in my teens, when we would go on Sunday mornings. I guess I “believed” ultimately because I felt I was supposed to. I had problems with the stuff coming out of the preacher’s mouth from a pretty early age – it just didn’t wash, even as a 13 or 14 year old. Plus, I saw a lot of hypocrisy and nonsense in the church and some of the church’s arcane doctrine. Still, especially as someone non-heterosexual, I struggled with that and thinking I was going to hell, etc. for a few years, before trying out some pagan spiritualities, and ultimately falling into the larger designation of agnostic.
I got raped (intellectually) by christians when I was going through a tough time years ago. Parasites attack when you are at your weakest.
I have to think about this but I have been involved in a number of different religons and spiritualities. I was searching, not for soemthing to justify my actions, but for something that enhanced my life through the spiritual knowledge that there is something there much more pwoerful than me. (not that I am all that powerful) I found a Higher Power in 12 step programs and eventually found me peace and spiritual strength in Zen Buddhism.
My husband is a Christian and I am a Zen Buddhist and we flow spiritualy together.
I am not sure if I answered your questions correctly but it is the only way i could say it:)
For me it is whatever floats your cheerios or whatever doesn”t. I think we are all uniquely different individuals and that si what makes like so interesting. Wish we could all just accept each other.
i was simply raised to believe that Christianity dominated everything. i’m not even sure i understood that other religions existed. as far as i knew, God’s existence had been proven and every single person i knew was Christian. i felt very deceived. one, i did have spiritual experiences… but none really connected me with Christianity in particular. two, i was deluded into thinking that religion is anything BUT your experiences.
I was raised in a household that swung back and forth between religion (Christianity) as the be-all, end-all and religion as nonexistent. Religion has been a struggle for me throughout most of my life because the churches I did go to as a young’un taught that you never, ever question God. Ever. On anything. Oh, and don’t screw up because you’re going to hell. The conflict was especially rough during the period of time that I was struggling with my sexuality. Reconciling myself, my bisexuality and my religious beliefs has been quite a journey.
I was raised in Oklahoma on a diet of Oklahoma Brand Southern Baptist-Influenced Religion (TM). I’ve rejected that, but that doesn’t mean I’ve forgotten my Christian roots entirely. I fall somewhere in a camp of Christian-Unitarian Universalist-Pluralist with a fascination for other religions. I don’t at all believe I have been brainwashed into believing anything at this point in my life (although I would say that I was when I was younger). Rather, I believe because I have to. To me, the idea of there not being anything greater than my little self, that all of this (whatever “this” is), is all there is in the universe, is about the most depressing thing I have ever heard. Personally, I *have* to believe there is more and we aren’t just freak accidents of life hurtling through space on a giant rock with no end purpose.
@justjase - I’m from Oklahoma, too. What you describe reflects the experience of actually quite a few people I know. I guess Oklahoma Brand Religion (TM) isn’t quite as popular as The Powers That Be would have us think.
@LovesTwo - Well, I think it is with some people!
A lot, even. However, I’d chalk it up to more and more people from my generation who are or are becoming non-religious (or certainly “less” religious, if anything). What part of OK, if I may ask? 
@LovesTwo - “the churches I did go to as a young’un taught thatyou never, ever question God. Ever. On anything.” – EXACTLY
So are you no longer a Christian Kirsten?
Start HERE then work forward.
I was raised to be nothing. I sometimes say that I was raised to be atheist but I don’t think that’s actually how I was raised. I wasn’t really told there was no God, but rather told about the scientific theories and stuff. But not until I was much older did my dad say that he didn’t believe in God. We celebrated all Christian holidays and during elementary school I regularly attended church. I do believe in God, but I can’t explain to you how I came to that at all. I remember asking my dad about where all the stuff came from to create the Big Bang and he didn’t know. At some point, I started to go to church or as my parents treated it “free babysitting”. lol I don’t know when I began to realize it was about a religion but I was in first grade before I found out there was a guy named Jesus and that Christmas wasn’t only about Santa Claus.
@The_Croteau - http://kristenmomof3.xanga.com/762308726/answering-the-question/ I have been an atheist for over a year…close to two years
I was an atheist. Never went to church or anything. My Catholic friends tried to get me going but I only went once for maskerade party but I would of been kicked out if they knew I wasn’t a member. It wasn’t until I was almost done with elementary school, my mom turned to Christ and started living her life according to the Bible. The change on her was immediate. She was changing for the better and she’s only been growing better and nicer by the day. It was after I saw the example in her life that I decided to turn my life around as well couse I wanted to be a better person to myself and to those around me – and I was not a nice person to be around with. I hope that answers your question at least a little bit.
@Kristenmomof3 – may I ask why? What happened for you to turn from God?
@The_Croteau -
The reality is when I started I
really had no intention of leaving Christianity behind. The idea that I
would be where I am today was the farthest outcome that I had expected
me to be in. In fact I tried really hard to cling to Christianity
through the whole process. For
me the process began with our movement toward Messianic Judaism.
Traditional Christianity in most ways seemed wrong….like something was
missing. My thought was that if I believed that god existed then I
believed that he desired me to be the best Christian that I could be. So
my journey began with the thought of “what are god’s expectations for a
Christian to be one of his followers?” That
brought me into Kosher Law, Sabbath Law, Gentile requirements and the
like. I gladly started to understand some of the laws and started to
apply them to my life. I applied them to my life because I thought they
were the will of god and had no ill or bad feelings about doing such
things….in fact I found joy in them. It
was around this time, that I seemed be reading blogs on various
Biblical issues and saw that each issue had numerous answers most in
conflict with each other. At the time, I viewed such discrepancies as
more of a political stance of the specific church of the person making
the comment. So, that lead me to the question “What was the real stance
for Christians to take on those issues?” I mean if we are of one
body….we should be of one mind and Christianity reminded me of a body
with Multiple Personality Disorder. So it was back to the question “What
does god want?” You
would think that answers would be easy, I mean we had the book that had
all the answers….but that could not have been further from the truth.
Finding answers was hard. Each issue had multiple bible verses and each
Bible verse had to be taken to its original Greek Hebrew or Aramaic. In
the end, I found out that there was some issues that when all boiled
down had conflicting answers. Some Hebrew and Greek words have no
English definitions meaning that we really don’t know what it actually
meant…bible scholars just took what ever they thought it meant or what
ever the cause was for the church of that century. This
brought me to the question…..”If they did that, what else could have
been tweaked to serve their own reasons?” the answer for me was “Start
at the beginning and find our the truth…..Genesis here I come. Some of the rules I had was …1.
All scripture is God breathed and useful for teaching, correcting,
rebuking and training in righteousness. Which leads to number two2. All stances had to be supported by other verses besides just one and all verses had to be taken in context. I had a few others but these were the most important…. Genesis
was where the axis started tipping. Obviously the first issue to come
up was the old Evolution verses Creation Debate. Having gone to a
Mennonite school…Evolution was not in the curriculum. So I basically
was able to start at square one. I acquired all the books, blogs,
Websites and debates I could on the subject of evolution and creation.
This process was long and for every point made for evolution there was
an answer for creation and visa versa. Then I read a book by of all
people Richard Dawkin’s called ” The Greatest Show On Earth” I was
hesitant about reading this because he was a staunch atheist who has a
very I would say strong but strong is an understatement, view against
god. But I found his book to be strongly informative. It made a very
compelling case for evolution and the evolutionary process. It cited
experiments that could be researched and you could see if the same
conclusions he stated were the conclusions of the scientists as well.
This book was the turning point to my acceptance of evolutions ….over
time I accepted evolution as fact and creation was a myth. Up
until this point I still wrote on my blog like there was nothing
wrong….bible studies….but sometimes my questions and doubts shone
through. From
there the questions kept coming like …..If creation was a myth what
about Adam and eve and marriage?….who can get married?…… Did god
create evil?…..Why does god allow bad things?…….if god doesn’t do
bad things why does seem to be oblivious to some Christians in times of
extreme distress?….why are we called to be fruitful and multiply and
yet some godly people left barren?…..is slavery really wrong?….what
is the role of women in christianity?…. For
every question….there was enough material to make your head spin and
you had to dig for an answer…. eventually it finally came down to
there were a lot of conflicting answers (and sometimes no answers) for
the first time I asked myself “What if god was not real….What if god
really isn’t there? …..I was conflicted had I spent all this time to
find what god wanted to only find out that god might not exist. So
my efforts now turned to the conflicts that nonchristians had with the
bible…..I figured that this was a do or die situation….. Either I
was gonna prove to myself that god existed or it was just a
myth…..again i went to books, blogs, websites and debates….and again
I had enough material to go through……..eventually over time the
Christian self was eroded away until one day I came to the conclusion
….Christianity is a myth…..and bye golly, I’m anatheist…………So the short answer is my journey from Christianity was because of the search for truth……
WAS TAUGHT THAT JEWISH WAS A RACE WHICH WAS WHY MY MOTHER AND MY GRANDFATHER HAD BIG EAGLE NOSES AND THE WORD JEWISH AND THE WORD HOLOCAUST HAVE BEEN IN THE SAME SENTENCE SINCE I WAS ABOUT 6 YEARS OLD.
WAS TAUGHT THAT CHRISTIANS BELIEVE IN JESUS AND I DIDN’T SO I WAS GONNA GET MY ASS KICKED BY THE BOYS WHO WENT TO SAINT CASSIAN’S. A CATHOLIC SCHOOL.
THIS HAD LITTLE OR NOTHING TO DO WITH GOD. AND EVERYTHING TO DO WITH BEATINGS. MY PARENTS SERIOUSLY BELIEVE THAT HITLER ALMOST CAME TO AMERICA. THEY ARE RIGHT.
I was raised baptist. Around 7, I felt…different. Things didn’t seem right to me. I seriously thought there was something wrong with me. Then at 12, I met someone openly Wiccan. Wait there are more people that don’t believe in God? I felt much better and became openly atheist…which was terrible. My family would say VERY mean things to me. I thought about Wicca for a while but couldn’t bring myself to worship anyone…so I just call myself Pagan.